Skip Navigation
Attorney General Bill SchuetteMichigan.gov
Michigan.gov Home
close print view

Schuette Renews Challenge to Obamacare

Contact: John Sellek or Joy Yearout 517-373-8060

January 5,  2011

            LANSING -  Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette today announced the renewal of Michigan's constitutional challenge to the federal healthcare law commonly known as "Obamacare."  Schuette will file paperwork in the U.S. District Court in Florida adding his name as a representative of the People of Michigan in the case.  Schuette's lawsuit questions the authority of the federal government under the Commerce Clause to force citizens to purchase health insurance and challenges the vast expansion of the Medicaid program in violation of state sovereignty under the 10th Amendment. 

"For the first time in history the federal government is forcing us to buy a product under the threat of a penalty, in violation of the U.S. Constitution," said Schuette.  "I will fight Obamacare tooth-and-nail to protect our citizens from this constitutional overreach."

Michigan is joined by twenty states and the National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB) in the healthcare lawsuit filed in the United States Northern District Court of Florida.  On December 16, 2010, District Court Judge Roger Vinson heard oral arguments for the case.  A written ruling is expected in the coming weeks. 

NFIB Michigan State Director Charles Owens praised Schuette's decision to continue the legal challenge.  "We are thankful that Attorney General Bill Schuette has the courage to stand up to this federal overreach and we are proud to join him and the other state Attorneys General in continuing this lawsuit," said Owens.  "We are disappointed that the current administration finds the U. S. Constitution to be an inconvenience.  Small business owners everywhere are rightfully concerned that the unconstitutional mandates, countless paperwork requirements, rules and taxes in the new healthcare law will seriously impair their ability to create jobs at a time when our country so desperately needs them."

On October 14, 2010, Judge Vinson denied the Obama Administration's efforts to dismiss the lawsuit, allowing the states' two primary claims to proceed: one count challenging the Constitutionality of the individual mandate, and a second count challenging the commandeering of state resources to expand the Medicaid program in violation of Article 1 of the U.S. Constitution and the Ninth and Tenth Amendments. 

Michigan's challenge to the healthcare law is separate from the lawsuit filed by Virginia, which has already earned a favorable ruling from the court.  Like Michigan's case, the Virginia case questions the federal government's authority to force Americans to purchase a product as the price of citizenship.  

 On December 13, 2010, U.S. District Court Judge Henry Hudson issued a ruling in favor of Virginia's challenge to federal health care legislation.  Judge Hudson struck down the individual mandate, noting in his opinion that the Minimum Essential Coverage Provision "exceeds the constitutional boundaries of congressional power" (p. 38). Judge Hudson also rejected the Obama administration's arguments regarding congressional authority under the Commerce Clause.

 

-30-

Related Content
 •  Seeking Justice for Fungal Meningitis Victims: Michigan A.G. Schuette Joins Federal Officials for Boston Announcement of Multiple Criminal Indictments Following Investigation of New England Compounding ...
 •  Wyant, Schuette Issue Statement on Enbridge U.P. Pipeline Incident Following Pipeline Task Force Meeting
 •  Schuette: Using Detroit DDA Funds to Develop New Hockey Arena is Constitutional
 •  Schuette: President's Immigration Order Oversteps Constitutional Bounds
 •  Schuette, Spaniola: Mason Circuit Court to Proceed with Murder Charge Against Sean Phillips
 •  Schuette Announces $3.8 Million Consumer Protection Settlement with Sirius XM
 •  Attorney General Schuette's Statement on House Passage of Prison Reform Legislation
 •  Schuette Applauds the National #GivingTuesday Movement to Encourage Spending With A Purpose
 •  Schuette Urges FTC to Update the Telemarketing Sales Rule to Protect Consumers
 •  Statement by Attorney General Schuette on SCOTUS Decision to Review Michigan v. EPA Case
 •  Schuette Partners with Nonprofits to Help Michigan Citizens Make Smart Donations
 •  Attorney General Schuette's Statement on Proposed Sentencing Reform Legislation
 •  Schuette Fights Excessive Electric Rates for Upper Peninsula Residents
 •  Schuette: This Veterans Day, Two New Legal Guides Available to Michigan Military Families and Veterans
 •  Statement by Attorney General Schuette on Detroit Bankruptcy Ruling
 •  Attorney General Schuette Supports Swift Appeal of 6th Circuit Ruling in DeBoer v. Snyder
 •  Schuette Announces $747,000 in Restitution for Southeast Michigan Victims of Mortgage Fraud
 •  Statement by Attorney General Schuette on 6th Circuit Ruling in DeBoer v. Snyder
 •  Schuette Files Child Abuse Charges Against Washtenaw County Man
 •  Schuette Announces More Than $500,000 for 5,600 Michigan Propane Consumers in AmeriGas Settlement
QR code

Michigan.gov Home
PoliciesMichigan NewsMichigan.gov Survey


Copyright © 2014 State of Michigan