Skip Navigation
Attorney General Bill SchuetteMichigan.gov
Michigan.gov Home
close print view

Schuette Preserves Right to Defend Pension Clause in Constitution at U.S. Court of Appeals for 6th Circuit

Contact: Joy Yearout 517-373-8060

May 27,  2014

LANSING Attorney General Bill Schuette today filed a statement in support of the Pension Clause of the Michigan Constitution for the pending bankruptcy appeal filed by retirees in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 6th Circuit.

"I recognize the hardship bankruptcy has caused, and the hardships facing pensioners, whose future is uncertain," said Schuette.  "The City's pensioners have a legal right to vote on this grand bargain, and I support their authority to decide these complex issues within the democratic process.  Pensioners may choose to waive their Constitutional protections, make adjustments to their retirement plans, and settle this case."

"However, if a settlement is not reached, I will continue to aggressively defend the pension clause in the Michigan Constitution, Article 9, Section 24, in bankruptcy court, and at the U.S. Court of Appeals."

In the Statement of Support for Oral Argument filed today, Schuette notes Michigan taxpayers are not on the hook for the City's potential pension fund shortfalls [emphasis added below]:

…the latter portion of Michigan's Pension Clause must be given effect, with the result that accrued financial benefits cannot be treated as ordinary contractual obligations, but are protected from any unilateral diminishment or impairment.  Applying the text of the Pension Clause as written, the City may not ask the bankruptcy court to approve a plan of adjustment that reduces pension benefits over the objection of members.  The City's duty under the Pension Clause is underscored by the second paragraph, which directs the City to fund accruing financial obligations on a yearly basis.  And it is the City alone, not the State or its taxpayers, that bears this obligation.  1976 Mich. Op. Att'y Gen. No. 5076, pp. 563, 565 (Aug. 9, 1976) ("the state is not ultimately liable for funding or paying the benefits of local government retirement programs.") (Pp. 23-24)

 

Pensioners May Voluntarily Waive Constitutional Rights

Earlier this month, Schuette announced an agreement with the City of Detroit to extend the deadline for his comments on the city's proposed Plan of Adjustment until the city's pensioners, including retired cops and firefighters, have had the opportunity to vote on whether they will accept the proposed Plan. Schuette is preserving the right to file a statement in defense of Michigan's pension clause of the state Constitution, depending on the pensioners' vote, which is scheduled to end on July 11, 2014.   The order and briefing schedule allows for Schuette to file comments on the Plan on two dates: June 22, 2014 and July 17, 2014.

In keeping with past filings, Schuette noted that honoring the pensioners' vote on the proposed Plan of Adjustment is consistent with existing legal precedent allowing certain rights to be subject to negotiation (Cranford v. Wayne County, Stone v. State).   Under the Pension Clause, the pension plans are Constitutional obligations of the City.  

As noted in the Attorney General's original statement filed in August 2013, the freedom to contract permits parties to mutually modify their existing agreements through a formal waiver acknowledging voluntary relinquishment of a known right or advantage.  In that vein, the Michigan Supreme Court has recognized that "[t]here is no question that a constitutional right can be contractually relinquished[.]"  Stone v. State, 651 N.W.2d 64, 66 (Mich. 2002).

[Copy of Brief Addressing Michigan's Constitutional Protections of Vested Pensions]

 

-30-

Related Content
 •  Schuette Announces Support for Federal Bills to Provide Restitution for Child Victims of Pornography: "Child Pornography is not a victimless crime"
 •  Schuette Charges Lapeer County Woman for Embezzling $460k from 136 Elderly Nursing Home Residents
 •  Schuette Offers Five Tips for Flood-Damaged Families to Avoid Scammers Attracted by FEMA Payments
 •  A.G. Schuette Commends Gov. Snyder's Signature on Bills Strengthening Sexual Assault Victims' Rights
 •  Schuette Announces $105 Million National Settlement with AT&T Mobility Over Cell Phone ‘Cramming'
 •  Schuette Announces Extradited Saginaw Man to Proceed to Trial for Running Massive Ponzi Scheme
 •  Schuette Praises Legislature for Passing Comprehensive Victim-Centered Bills to Fight Human Trafficking
 •  A.G. Schuette Marks National Bullying Prevention Month, Encourages Students to Use OK2SAY to Report Bullying, Cyberbullying
 •  Schuette Charges Manistee Co. Pair With Premeditated First Degree Murder in 1995 Cold Case
 •  Schuette Praises House Committee for Unanimous Passage of Legislation to Protect Patients
 •  Schuette Announces AG Investigation in Alleged Aramark Employee Murder-for-Hire in Chippewa County
 •  Schuette Secures $1.6 Million for Michigan in Historic Settlement with European-Based Drug Company for Unlawful ADHD Drug Marketing
 •  A.G. Schuette Joins Law Enforcement, Education Leaders to Announce Statewide Student Safety Initiative, OK2SAY
 •  AG Schuette Commends Senate Passage of Bills Strengthening Sexual Assault Victims' Rights
 •  AG Propane Investigation Update: Schuette Secures $100k Relief for Ferrellgas Customers, Goes to Court to Fight for AmeriGas Customers
 •  Schuette, Spaniola Will Appeal Dismissal of Murder Charge Against Sean Phillips
 •  Schuette, Getting Charge Tennessee Man in Kalamazoo Rape Cold Case
 •  Schuette Urges FCC to Protect Consumers from Unwanted Robocalls and Phone Scams
 •  Cheboygan District Court Orders Chesapeake Energy Corp. to Proceed to Trial on Racketeering Charges
 •  Schuette Files Criminal Charges Against Genesee Co. Family for 2013 Hit and Run Death of Jeffrey Lee
QR code

Michigan.gov Home
PoliciesMichigan NewsMichigan.gov Survey


Copyright © 2014 State of Michigan