Dock Collapse into Detroit River from Detroit Bulk Storage Site

LATEST UPDATE

June 16, 2020: An online public hearing was held on Revere Dock LLC’s Detroit River dock collapse restoration plan. Nearly 80 people attended the online presentation and hearing. Many asked questions or offered comments on the proposal. The plan – a copy of which is posted below under “Documents” as “PM Environmental / Revere Dock LLC River Bank Restoration Plan (891 pages)” – proposes to remove material deposited in the river from the collapse as well as river sediments, build a 600-foot-long steel sea wall, and plans for controlling erosion, sedimentation and turbidity in the water during construction to comply with any local, state and federal regulations that apply to the restoration project.

A recording of the June 16 Public Hearing on the Application for Permit by Revere Dock, LLC is available on EGLE’s YouTube channel.

EGLE Document List

EPA Revere Dock Site Resources


March 30, 2020: The consulting firm hired by Revere Dock LLC submitted to EGLE the River Bank Restoration Plan for the site in Detroit where an aggregate spill collapsed a dock and associated soil into the Detroit River. The plan was required of Revere by EGLE to detail how Revere Dock will address the dock collapse, remove materials within the river and restore the river bank. The report by PM Environmental contains two parts: Results of a geotechnical investigation and river bank failure material characterization activities and a restoration plan with a work timeline. EGLE staff is evaluating the report.

Jan. 31, 2020: EGLE’s Remediation and Redevelopment Division sent Revere Dock, LLC and Detroit Bulk Storage letters on Jan. 31 responding to the Jan. 24 Interim Response Plan submitted by Revere Dock, LLC. EGLE expressed additional concern about interim response efforts conducted to date to prevent soil contaminants from eroding into the river and requested additional measures be implemented immediately. A written update on additional actions taken including identifying contingency actions was requested to be submitted to EGLE by February 7, 2020.

Two staff on the bank of the detroit river collecting water samples

EGLE staff said the additional 20-foot silt curtain is not performing satisfactorily, and that the sinkhole at the site was not evaluated adequately and may be allowing additional materials from the property, including aggregate and contaminated soils, to enter the river. Settling is occurring in the pond area, which is 12 feet deep. EGLE requested Revere to conduct an expedited evaluation of the sinkhole and develop a plan to prevent further discharges of contaminated soil and aggregate into river now and in the future.

EGLE reviewed the proposed geotechnical assessment and required that the property be assessed from pre-collapse conditions to the present and provided review comments on the work proposed. EGLE also stated that the sampling strategy proposed was not appropriate and recommended discrete sampling be conducted, requested additional sampling locations, and discussed future requirements for seawall permits, dredging permits, and further review to be conducted by EGLE Water Resources Division staff for those permit applications.

Revere and DBS have until Feb. 29 to submit to EGLE an Progress Report and geotechnical investigation results, and until March 30 to submit a Restoration Plan Report, which is to detail longer-term and more specific plans to remediate the site.

Jan. 28, 2020: EGLE staff performed below water inspection of the ponded area at the Detroit Bulk Storage site with a remotely operated vehicle. EGLE staff also collected surface water samples from within and outside of the original 5-foot silt curtain that Revere Dock installed around the area of the collapse. Revere Dock crews began the installation of a second silt curtain, this one at 400 feet long and 20 feet deep – beyond the original 5-foot curtain.  The silt curtains are intended to contain further erosion of contaminated soil from the site, spilled aggregate, and river sediment from migrating away from the spill site.  

Posted in the document section below is the updated Interim Response Plan submitted to EGLE by Revere Dock and Detroit Bulk Storage. The plan was revised after EGLE told the companies their first version, filed with the state Jan. 10, was inadequate. EGLE staff in various divisions are reviewing the plan to determine the department’s level of satisfaction with document.

Jan. 17, 2020: EGLE Remediation and Redevelopment Division staff were on the Detroit River adjacent to the Revere Copper and Brass property to conduct a survey of the collapsed dock and soils within the impacted river area. Staff used sonar equipment to measure the depth of the river. The information gathered will be used to map the river bottom, showing the extent of the collapsed dock and soils within the Detroit River.

EGLE Staff use sonar equipment in Detroit River Staff analyze information about river bottom
EGLE Staff use sonar equipment in Detroit River Staff analyze information about river bottom

 

Jan. 16, 2020: EGLE’s Remediation and Redevelopment Division informed Revere Dock, LLC and Detroit Bulk Storage that the short-term steps they have taken to contain the impacts of the aggregate spill into the Detroit River are inadequate. In letters mailed Jan. 16, EGLE expressed concern about interim response efforts conducted to date to prevent soil contaminants from eroding into the river. Revere and DBS spelled out their plans in letters sent to EGLE on Jan. 10.

EGLE staff said a five-foot silt curtain does not surround the area of the bank failure, the southern portion of the bank collapse is not protected adequately from erosion, and a sinkhole at the site is developing rapidly in size and allowing additional materials from the property, including aggregate and contaminated soils, to enter the river. EGLE called for an expedited evaluation of the sinkhole and development of a plan to prevent further discharges of contaminated soils and aggregate into the river.

Revere and DBS have until Jan. 24 to submit to EGLE an Interim Response Plan, which is to detail longer-term and more specific plans to remediate the site. That plan must include an assessment of the sinkhole and proposed measures to ensure further contaminated soils and aggregate are not discharged into the Detroit River.

Jan. 16, 2020: The Great Lakes Water Authority received the results from a second round of water quality testing related to the Detroit Bulk Storage dock collapse in November. The results confirm there was no impact to water quality from the aggregate spill.

Jan. 10, 2020: Revere Dock LLC submitted to the state its response to notifications regarding the Detroit Bulk Storage aggregate spill site along the Detroit River. The document lists short-term steps Revere expects to take at the site. Revere had missed its Dec. 26 deadline to submit a plan to EGLE’s Water Resources Division, but it did meet it’s Jan. 10 deadline to submit its response to EGLE’s Remediation and Redevelopment Division.

Jan. 9, 2020: The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy is analyzing preliminary results of recent Environment Protection Agency soil and pond water sampling at the Detroit Bulk Storage site along the Detroit River, where an aggregate pile collapsed in November into the river. EGLE’s analysis of the results and further discussions with the EPA will inform our next steps to hold the site’s owner, Revere Dock LLC, and Detroit Bulk Storage accountable and ensure a cleanup that is protective of public health and the environment. Read the full statement.

Dec. 27, 2019: The Great Lakes Water Authority’s first round of water quality test results have been released and levels were “non-detect” for some metals, including uranium, thorium, mercury, and lead. Results for radionuclides are pending, according to GLWA.

Dec. 12, 2019: A violation notice for illegal filling of a bottomland without a permit has been issued to the owner of the property where a sediment pile collapsed into the Detroit River last month. The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy requires North Muskegon-based Ericksons -- which was leasing the property to property to Detroit Bulk Storage and Revere Dock – to provide a restoration plan within 15 days to remove the debris without disturbing potentially contaminated river bottom sediment below it. The plan must be approved by EGLE.

Dec. 11, 2019: All test results from water samples taken from the Detroit River upstream, downstream, and directly offshore from the collapse of a sediment pile show no elevated levels of pollutants. The tests showed no detectable levels of PCBs, uranium, heavy metals, Polynuclear Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs), and several other industrial pollutants. Suspended solids and barium were detected, but at levels well below water quality standards.

Previously, radiological testing conducted Friday, December 6, at the site showed radiation levels below background levels typically found in Michigan.

The site, commonly referred to as the Revere Copper & Brass site or Detroit Bulk Storage site, was previously contaminated by uranium processing. It was remediated in the 1980s and 1990s. Post-remediation testing showed no radiological contamination beyond background levels. The testing conducted by EGLE affirms that there is no current increased risk to the public or the environment from the collapse.

EGLE Staff surveys Detroit Bulk Storage site Group testing Detroit Bulk Storage site for radiation
EGLE Staff surveys Detroit Bulk Storage site Group testing Detroit Bulk Storage site for radiation
 
 

DOCUMENTS

Date of Document Description
April 15, 2020 Enforcement Notice: Revere Dock, LLC added 9/23/20
March 30, 2020 PM Environmental / Revere Dock, LLC River Bank Restoration Plan (891 pages)
March 5, 2020 EGLE Drone Site Investigation
Feb. 29, 2020 Revere Dock LLC Activities Progress Update
Feb. 14, 2020 EGLE Compliance Communication to Revere Dock, LLC
Feb. 7, 2020 Revere response to EGLE’s Jan. 31 Compliance Communication
Feb. 5, 2020 PM Environmental Bank Failure Area Aggregate Material Removal and Visual Stability Evaluation Summary
Feb. 5, 2020 Proposed Sampling Location Map
Jan. 31, 2020 Reply to Revere Dock, LLC Updated Interim Response Plan
Jan. 24, 2020 Revere Dock LLC Updated Interim Response Plan
Jan. 16, 2020 Reply to Detroit Bulk Storage letter
Jan. 16, 2020 Reply to Revere Dock, LLC letter
Jan. 10, 2020 Revere Dock, LLC response letter
Dec. 11, 2019 Violation Notice: Ericksons
Dec. 11, 2019 Due Care Letter: Revere Dock
Dec. 11, 2019 Due Care Letter: Detroit Bulk Storage
Dec. 11, 2019 Lab report: Multiple contaminants testing conducted by EGLE
Dec. 9, 2019 Lab report: PAHs report produced by Merit Laboratories, Inc.
Dec. 6, 2019 Sediment Collapse into the Detroit River FAQ (revised December 26, 2019)