Skip to main content

ET Decisions 2009

This is a list of decisions issued by the Tribunal in 2009.  The actual Opinions may be viewed by clicking on the docket number.  If you do not have Adobe Reader on your system, you will need to download a free copy of Adobe Reader in order to view the Opinions.

2026

2025

2024

2023

2022

2021

2020

2019

2018

2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

First Quarter

Docket # Case Name Issue Date
George Chedraue v Wayne County Treasurer
01/22/09
Richard B. & Robin M. Engel v Richland Twp
01/30/09
Donald Parker v West Bloomfield Twp
01/30/09
Lore Silberman Trust under Agreement dated 11/7/94 v Eveline Township
01/30/09
Randall Kohn v Columbus Twp
01/30/09
Polynorm Automotive North America v City of Novi
01/30/09
MI Montana LLC v Custer Twp
02/02/09
Viviano Flower Shop, Inc. v Treasury
02/12/09
BBF Holdings, LLC v Lawrence Twp
02/18/09
Michael Burt v Treasury
02/18/09
Broughton Development v Macomb Twp
02/25/09
Midway Sheet Metal v Dalton Twp
02/26/09
MTA Land Company, LLC v Dalton Twp
02/26/09
Gerald A. Van Hassel aka Dalton Enterprises v Dalton Twp
02/26/09
Woodworks Unlimited, Inc. v Dalton Twp
02/26/09
Dalton Enterprises v Dalton Twp
02/26/09
R.J. Woodworking v Dalton Twp
02/26/09
328938 Anchor of Hope Church of the Nazarene v Dalton Twp 02/26/09
338936 Trettco, Inc. v Mich Dept of Treasury 02/27/09
315338 & 329408 Ferndale Laboratories v City of Ferndale 03/18/09
341804 & 359201 Heartland Employment Services, LLC v Department of Treasury 03/18/09
327869 David & Deborah K. Reese v Lyon Twp 03/19/09
358562 Grace & Wild, Inc. v Treasury 03/26/09
329578 Arthur and Marlene Klein v C of Coopersville 03/27/09
355732 Scott & Brenda Wilson v Hill Twp. 03/31/09
322718 Stephen J. Quinn v Dept. of Treasury 03/31/09

Second Quarter

Docket #

Case Name

Issue Date

342101

Hunderman & Sons Redi-Mix, Inc v Treasury

04/02/09

353171

Revival Tabernacle Assembly of God v City of Highland Park

04/08/09

344354

Walter Toebe Construction Co. v Treasury

04/08/09

327024

Detroit Medical Center v City of Novi

04/08/09

333646(consolidated w/344631)

The Founders Group v Custer Township

04/08/09

310578

Kent Beverage Co., Inc. v City of Wyoming

04/13/09

324343

Haitham Masri, MD v Treasury

04/17/09

314441

Shree Raj Corp v Plainfield Twp

04/21/09

304542

Paul A. Snow v Treasury

05/20/09

320983
(Cons w/ 330138) and 326485

AEV, Inc., v City of Flint

06/03/09

314856

Lansing Tower Apartments v City of Lansing

06/10/09

329021

Michael J. Absher v Treasury

06/23/09

Third Quarter

Docket #

Case Name

Issue Date

330368

Bert Hazekamp & son, Inc. v Treasury

07/13/09

329920

Hoffman's Corner Store, Inc., v Treasury

07/17/09

332534

Richard & Robin Engel v Richland Twp

07/17/09

345600

The Wellness Plan v City of Oak Park

07/17/09

320519

Robert F. Hickey v Treasury (Corrected)

07/21/09

327974 357752, 352509 & 359178 FAW, LLC & GBM Apartments, LLC v Grand Blanc Twp (Corrected) 07/27/09

342253

Green Thumb Lawnscaping, Inc. v Treasury

07/31/09

350541 Enbridge Energy, Ltd. Partnership v Garden Township (Corrected) 08/06/09
350515 Enbridge Energy, Ltd. Partnership v Nahma Twp (Corrected) 08/08/09

337042

ABP MI (Detroit), LLC v Twp of Ypsilanti

08/26/09

300519

Palace Sports & Entertainment, Inc. v City of Auburn Hills

08/26/09

337849

Sears, Roebuck & Co v City of Novi

08/31/09

Highland-Howell Development Group v City of Howell
08/31/09
New Michigan LP v City of Roosevelt Park
09/01/09
TCF National Bank v Tyrone Twp
09/17/09

310739

President Inn Properties, LLC v City of Grand Rapids

09/17/09

Highland Howell Development Group, LLC v Marion Twp
09/23/09
327730 (Cons w/ 339495)
Kurt A. Weber v City of Pleasant Ridge
09/29/09

328350

U.S. Can. Hospitalities, LLP v City of Romulus

09/29/09

326490

New Michigan LP v City of Norton Shores

09/30/09

Fourth Quarter

Docket No.

Case Name

Issue Date

326489

New Michigan LP v City of Roosevelt Park

09/01/09

318948

TCF National Bank v Tyrone Twp

09/17/09

310739

President Inn Properties, LLC v City of Grand Rapids

09/17/09

307906

Highland Howell Development Group, LLC v Marion Twp

09/23/09

327730
(Cons w/ 339495)

Kurt A. Weber v city of Pleasant Ridge

09/29/09

328350

U.S. Can. Hospitalities, LLP v City of Romulus

09/29/09

326490

New Michigan LP v City of Norton Shores

09/30/09

321692
(Cons w 322292 & 328884)

Henry and Janet Marie Nino v Treasury

10/23/09

333799

Christopher Wenzlick v Village of Oakley

10/23/09

354554

Charter Oak Homes v City of Detroit

10/23/09

329406

G. Peter Molloy v Treasury

11/04/09

329583

Spartech Polycom v City of St. Clair

11/10/09

327410

MJC Chesterfield v Twp of Chesterfield

11/25/09

368062

Northport Public Schools v Leelanau Twp, Northport Village & the Northport/Leelanau Twp Utilities Authority

11/30/09

329877

Henry & Janet Nino v Treasury

11/30/09

315388

Rouge Steel Company v Treasury

11/30/09

337638

Karen’s Helping Hands, Inc v City of Riverview

11/30/09

310577

Arena Associates, Inc. v City of Rochester Hills

12/02/09

328268
(Cons w/ 328269,
328270, 328271,
328272, 328273,
328274, 328275,
328276, 328277,
328278, 328279,
328280, 328281, 328282 & 328283)

Keith N. Penner v Treasury

12/04/09

338870 SVC Realty v Fenton 12/04/09
337980R Richmond Street LLC v City of Walker
(Final on Remand)
12/04/09

308994
309000

318196

Calder Plaza Investors, LLC
New BVC Partners, LLC and
Partners V, LLC

12/11/09
328736 Louis D. Swartz v Michigan Dept of Treasury 12/29/09