Skip to main content

ET Decisions 2012

This is a list of decisions issued by the Tribunal in 2012. The actual Opinions may be viewed by clicking on the docket number. If you do not have Adobe Reader on your system, you will need to download a free copy of Adobe Reader in order to view the Opinions.

2026

2025

2024

2023

2022

2021

2020

2019

2018

2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

First Quarter

Docket No.

Case Name

Issue Date

354367

James and Karen Westphal v Ann Arbor

01/09/2012

359040

Patrick J. Hance v Treasury

01/09/2012

361531

Michigan Retail Partners v Big Rapids

01/10/2012

357602

Staffplus Michigan v Treasury

01/10/2012

385112

Jack A. Baas v Treasury

01/13/2012

354554r

Charter Oak Homes v Detroit

01/13/2012

361984

Lowe's Home Centers v Frenchtown Twp

01/18/2012

401004

Battle Creek Unlimited Inc v Battle Creek

02/02/2012

413879

David Knuth v Homer Twp

02/03/2012

285849

Knollwood Country Club v West Bloomfield

02/10/2012

358540

WCY Realty LLC v Fairhaven Twp

02/16/2012

366368

Thomas and Joyce Thelen v Kochville Twp

02/24/2012

363342

Eight Mile & Haggerty Land Co v Novi

03/02/2012

341589

Raycan Transport Inc v Treasury

03/06/2012

409401

GMO Threshold Timber Michigan v Eagle Arbor Twp

03/08/2012

361944

Target v Benton Twp

03/09/2012

354366

Jack Panitch and Pauline Park v Ann Arbor

03/13/2012

364574

Kool Real Estate LLC v Meridian Twp

03/13/2012

345544

ATC Properties LLC v Lansing

03/13/2012

366368e

Thomas and Joyce Thelen v Kochville Twp

03/14/2012

364571

Catalyst Development Co LLC v Kalamazoo

03/16/2012

361344

SEC Accommodator-Burwick Farms LLC v Howell

03/19/2012

350415

Cadence Innovations v Chesterfield Twp

03/19/2012

384364

HOV Services Inc v Treasury

03/19/2012

269883

Eastwick Square Townhouse Cooperative v Roseville

03/19/2012

333372

Farmington Village Co-Op v Farmington Hills

03/19/2012

361544

John Policicchio Trust v Charter Twp of Brownstown

03/20/2012

365693

FGY Inc v City of Niles

03/22/2012

411641

Sebastian J Mancuso Family Trust v Charlevoix

03/23/2012

357742

Miller-Bradford & Risberg Inc (Michael J Soley Sr) v Negaunee Twp and Marquette County

03/28/2012

357723

James Klecha v Treasury

03/28/2012

401982

Jersey Marshal, Inc v City of Marshall

03/28/2012

401985

Jersey Marshal, Inc v City of Marshall

03/28/2012

409452

Joseph and Jaqueline Jurkiewicz v Hill Twp

03/28/2012

359228

David L and Vicki L Anderson v Treasury

03/28/2012

392627

Hill Road Storage Center v Mundy Twp

03/29/2012

365867

Schefenacker Vision Systems USA v Marysville

03/30/2012

Second Quarter

Docket No.

Case Name

Issue Date

409399

GMO Threshold Timber Michigan LLC v Eagle Harbor

04/02/2012

409400

GMO Threshold Timber Michigan LLC v Eagle Harbor

04/02/2012

361963

Target Corporation v City of Midland

04/04/2012

341982

KC Transportation Inc v Treasury

04/05/2012

320438

Elm Investment Co v Detroit

04/10/2012

366618

Brighton Hotel Suites Inc v Brighton

04/23/2012

361955

Target Corp v Auburn Hills

04/24/2012

402616

AFR Enterprises, Inc. v Kimball Twp.

04/30/2012

431811

Donald and Ronald Lewallen v Porter Twp.

05/04/2012

422744

Roe-Comm, Inc. v Treasury

05/07/2012

410948

Brian Bonar v Treasury

05/29/2012

362195

Redford Square Associates v Redford Twp

05/29/2012

410949

John Podmajersky, et al v Treasury

06/05/2012

365860

B&L Development v City of Norton Shores

06/13/2012

368166

IGWT Monroe LLC v Charter Twp of Frenchtown

06/20/2012

432282

Irish Construction Co v Treasury

06/26/2012

Third Quarter

Docket No.

Case Name

Issue Date

Harmony Montessori Center v City of Oak Park

9/26/2012

Eight-Haggerty Properties II,L.P. v City of Novi

9/21/2012

Eight-Haggerty Properties II,L.P. v City of Novi

9/21/2012

E.H. Tulgestka & Sons Inc. v Michigan Department of Treasury
9/19/2012
Nagmuddin A Pady v City of Detroit
9/9/2012
MJR Group LLC v Michigan Department of Treasury
9/27/2012

Fourth Quarter

Docket No.

Case Name

Issue Date

322530

Second Impressions Inc v City of Kalamazoo

10/23/2012

Grand haven Investment, LLC v Spring Lake Township

10/31/2012

366425 Home Depot USA v Breitung Township 12/26/2012
Roger J. Christel Living Trust v City of Center Line

10/8/2012

Diversified Machine, Inc. v City of Montague
10/31/2012
Michael Lynch v City of Novi
11/15/2012
Premier Land Development LLC v Township of Martiny
12/6/2012
Premier land Development LLC v Township of Martiny
12/6/2012
Premier land Development LLC v Township of Martiny
12/6/2012
373080 Premier land Development LLC v Township of Martiny 12/6/2012
Mahavir and Viajanthi Oza v Township of West Bloomfield
12/6/2012
Crescent House, LLC v City of Detroit
1/14/2013
HJS Village Square Property Co., LLC d/b/a Village Square Apartments
1/14/2013
HJS Central Park Apartments, LLC d/b/a Central Park Apartments
1/14/2013
Congregation Yagdil Torah v City of Southfield
11/29/2012
Star International Academy v City of Dearborn Heights
12/6/2012

385097

CNJ Properties, LLC v West Bloomfield Township
11/8/2012
Lowe's Home Centers, Inc v Township of Marquette
12/13/2012
Dundee Riverfront, LLC v Dundee Township
12/6/2012
Bristol Law Real Estate, LLC
12/28/2012
Occidental Development, LLC v Township of Waterford
1/14/2013
Spartan Stores, Inc. and Family Fare, LLC v City of Grand Rapids
12/5/2012
Elian 2 Corporation v Michigan Department of Treasury
12/12/2012
Eric W. Gaer v Michigan Department of Treasury
10/16/2012
Great Lakes Home Health Services, Inc v Michigan Department of Treasury
10/23/2012
R&L Carriers Shared Services, LLC v Michigan Department of Treasury
12/26/2012
General Mills Operations, LLC v Michigan Department of Treasury
11/28/2012
South Lyon Apartment, LLC v Michigan Department of Treasury
11/30/2012
Michael Limauro v Michigan Department of Treasury
10/24/2012
Evangel Association of Churchers & Ministries v City of Roseville
12/6/2012
Evangel Association of Churchers & Ministries v City of Roseville
12/6/2012
Evangel Christian Churches v City of Roseville
12/6/2012
Evangel Christian Churches v City of Roseville
12/6/2012
Evangel Ministries International v City of Roseville
12/6/2012
Schoeneckers, Inc. v Michigan Department of Treasury
10/23/2012
Great Lakes West LLC v Michigan Department of Treasury
12/10/2012
Meritax, LLC as Agent for CVS #8024-02 v City of Richmond
10/18/2012
Jeffrey Denha v Michigan Department of Treasury
12/12/2012
Charles T. Russell v Michigan Department of Treasury
12/12/2012
Sovereign Sales, LLC v Michigan Department of Treasury
11/28/2012
Peaker Services, Inc. v Michigan Department of Treasury
12/5/2012
Paul S. Zaccagni v Michigan Department of Treasury
10/4/2012
Prophetic Word Ministries, Inc v City of Saugatuck
11/16/2012
Rockford Sportsman's Club v Township of Algoma
10/19/2012

448699

Clifford J. Dovitz v Michigan Department of Treasury
12/10/2012