Skip to main content

Wixom WWTP Biosolids Fields Area of Interest (Wixom, Livingston County)

Disclaimer: Web content may not be routinely updated on this page.

Please contact the Site Lead for the most up-to-date status of this site.

EGLE site Lead

Sydney Ruhala, RuhalaS@Michigan.gov or 517-599-5356.

MDARD site lead

For questions related to crop/beef sampling and farm management, please contact:

Christine Kosmowski, KosmowskiC@Michigan.gov or 517-599-6467.

Background

The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy (EGLE), sampled the effluent (i.e. the treated wastewater discharged from the treatment plant) and biosolids for PFAS at the city of Wixom Wastewater Treatment Plant (WWTP) ) in 2018 as part of the Statewide Wastewater Treatment Plant and Biosolids PFAS Study. Results indicated that high levels of PFAS, specifically PFOS, were being passed through the treatment process at the plant. PFOS levels were 269 parts per trillion (ppt) in the effluent and 2,150 parts per billion (ppb) in the biosolids.

Biosolids are the nutrient-rich organic materials resulting from the treatment of domestic sewage in a WWTP. Biosolids can be a beneficial resource, contain essential plant nutrient and organic matter, and are recycled as soil conditioner.

The city of Wixom has an EGLE approved Residuals Management Plan, which has allowed the WWTP to land apply biosolids produced at the plant since 2000. The city of Wixom WWTP stopped land application of biosolids in the Spring of 2018 and has since sent accumulated sludge to a landfill. The city has worked with the sources of the PFOS--two industrial facilities that discharge wastewater to the WWTP--to install treatment to remove PFAS at the source and have since seen significant reductions in PFOS concentrations in both the effluent and biosolids generated at the WWTP.

Due to the high levels of PFOS found in the biosolids, EGLE evaluated land application sites that historically received biosolids from the city of Wixom WWTP. Following a field selection process which considered PFAS levels in biosolids, application amounts and rates, acreage used, soil types and other factors, five fields located in Livingston County were selected for sampling. The objective was to determine if there was any impact from the land application of industrially impacted biosolids containing high amounts of PFOS to the soil, groundwater, or adjacent surface water bodies. Crop and eventual beef sampling was also conducted by MPART.

Estimated groundwater flow direction varies across the site, including southwest, northwest, and northeast across the biosolids fields, depending on location.

Four residential wells and one livestock well adjacent to the biosolids fields were tested for PFAS in November 2019 as part of the investigation. All five wells were non-detect for PFAS. Out of abundance of caution, EGLE tested an additional 20 residential wells near the biosolids fields for PFAS in October 2021. PFAS was not detected in 18 of the 20 wells. Two wells had PFAS detections below the drinking water criteria. One of the two wells where PFAS was detected was also resampled in December 2021 and PFAS detections were below the drinking water criteria. The source of PFAS in the two residential wells with detections is unknown.

Content updated December 2023.

Drinking water

57 residential wells have been sampled. EGLE will expand residential drinking water well testing in the area if determined to be necessary.

Anticipated activities

EGLE will continue to work to determine the extent of PFAS contamination in the area of the biosolids fields.

Historical timeline

    • In April 2019, EGLE contractors sampled soil, surface water, perched (i.e., standing) water and a tile drain for PFAS at two biosolids fields. Locations of soil samples were selected based on previous studies, soil types, surface water flow and were generally biased towards areas with the highest potential to be impacted.
    • In August 2019, EGLE contractors installed three pairs of nested groundwater monitoring wells (one deep and one shallow at each location) at two biosolids fields.
    • In September 2019, EGLE contractors sampled the groundwater monitoring wells installed in August 2019 for PFAS. PFAS was not detected in the three deep wells. PFAS was detected in two of the shallow wells, at concentrations below criteria.
    • In November 2019, EGLE contractors sampled soil, surface water, and perched water on an additional two biosolids fields. EGLE contractors also tested water from four residential drinking water wells and one livestock well adjacent to the biosolids fields. All five wells were non-detect for PFAS.
    • In November 2019 – 2021, MPART contractors collected grasses (sorghum), corn silage, and haylage per a request from MDARD, so MDARD could determine if the crops were uptaking PFAS from the biosolids fields. Samples were processed by Eurofins for Michigan Department of Health and Human Services (MDHHS) lab analysis. There are no standards for sampling, processing, or analysis of crops. In the spring of 2021, the analytical results were received.
      • In March 2021, EGLE contractors resampled the three pairs of nested groundwater monitoring wells originally installed in August 2019 for PFAS. PFAS was non-detect in two of the three deep wells. Low-level concentrations of PFAS were detected in one of the deep wells, but results were below protection criteria. PFAS was also detected in two of the three shallow wells, one of which had PFOA above criteria at 16.4 ppt.
      • In April 2021, EGLE published the Evaluation of Wixom Wastewater Treatment Plant (WWTP) Biosolids Land Application Sites 02N05E01-BC01 & BC02, 02N05E02-BC01 & AG01 03N06E04-JW01 & JW05 report which summarizes the sampling completed at the biosolids fields in 2019.  
      • Over the summer and fall of 2021, MPART worked with the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to evaluate the results, develop a risk assessment model to determine potential health concerns from meat consumption, and discuss beef sampling.
      • September 2021: MPART Presentation – Wixom Precautionary Residential Well Sampling
      • On October 8, 2021, EGLE contractors collected samples of water from an additional 20 residential drinking water wells out of an abundance of caution. Testing showed that 18 of 20 wells were non-detect for PFAS. PFAS was detected in two of the wells, both of which were below protection criteria.
      • On December 6, 2021, MDHHS resampled one of the two residential drinking water wells where PFAS was detected in October 2021. Results are pending.
      • On December 13 to December 15, 2021, EGLE and their contractor conducted incremental soil sampling and manure sampling at two of the five biosolids fields. Sampling was completed to better understand how PFAS concentrations vary across different portions of the fields to help the farmer make management decisions.
        • There are currently no PFAS standards for soil or manure.
      • On December 30, 2021, EGLE received the results from the incremental soil and manure sampling. Testing showed lower PFAS concentrations in soil on portions of the fields that received less biosolids than the portions that received biosolids more frequently.
    • In January 2022, based on the results of the risk assessment model MPART determined beef should be sampled. Frozen beef samples were sent to United States Department Agriculture for analysis.
    • On January 28, 2022, MDHHS issued a consumption advisory due to finding PFOS in the beef.
    • On April 7 and 8, 2022, EGLE contractors collected samples of water from an additional 30 residential drinking water wells out of an abundance of caution. PFAS was non-detect in all 30 wells.
    • On April 27, 2022, EGLE collected samples of water from an additional two residential drinking water wells out of an abundance of caution. One well was non-detect for PFAS, while PFAS was detected in the second well below criteria. The source of PFAS in the well with detections is unknown. EGLE also collected a surface water sample along one of the biosolids fields where a spring was present. PFOS was detected in the surface water sample above criteria at 22.7 ppt.
    • On May 11, 2022, EGLE collected a sample of water from one additional residential drinking water well out of an abundance of caution. The well was non-detect for PFAS.
    • On June 6, 2022, EGLE held a virtual meeting for local residents who had their drinking water wells tested for PFAS to share the results and answer questions.     
    • In June 2023, EGLE published an addendum to the Evaluation of Wixom Wastewater Treatment Plant (WWTP) Biosolids Land Application Sites 02N05E01-BC01 & BC02, 02N05E02-BC01 & AG01 03N06E04-JW01 & JW05 report summarizing additional investigations in the area from 2020 to 2022.

      Sampling Results Summary

      Type of Sample

      Date Sampled (or Range)

      Numberof Sample Results Received

      Number of Samples above Criteria*

      Groundwater Monitoring Wells

      September 2019 - March 2021 6 1
      Residential Wells November 2019 -May 2022 57 0
      Surface Water April - May 2022 13 12
      * Residential well and groundwater monitoring well results are compared to EGLE Part 201 criteria for 7 PFAS compounds effective 12/21/2020:  PFOS (16 ppt), PFOA (8 ppt), PFNA (6 ppt), PFHxS (51 ppt), PFHxA (400,000 ppt), PFBS (420 ppt), and HFPO-DA (370 ppt).
      * Surface water samples are compared to Rule 57 non-drinking water values of 12 ppt for PFOS, 170 ppt for PFOA, and 670,000 ppt for PFBS.

      Sampling Notes

      • The 2019 surface water samples were collected from four surface water ponds located adjacent to the biosolids fields as well as 8 locations with standing water on the fields.