Step 1: Determine which public benefit category (accessibility, capacity, efficiency or public safety) best fits the project’s goals. Refer to the bullets under each following category for examples. It is possible for a project to fit under more than one category.
Step 2: Identify the specific public benefit(s). You must define a specific public benefit that can be measured before and after construction. Refer to the public benefit examples under each category below.
Step 3: Describe how the public benefit improvement will be measured and reported. You must define how you plan to measure the change in accessibility, capacity, efficiency, etc. Refer to the possible reporting measures under each of the following categories.
Example:
Your proposed project involves mainline tie and rail replacement, the goal being to improve track speeds and remove slow orders. Overall, you see this project as an improvement in efficiency.
Public Benefit: the project will improve efficiency by increasing track speeds from FRA Class 1 to FRA Class 2. This is a specific public benefit that can be measured.
Reporting Measure: the improvement in efficiency will be measured by providing employee timetables documenting the maximum operating speeds for this section of track before and after project completion. This is a specific method of measuring the public benefit.
Accessibility
- Projects that provide rail access to new customers and/or result in new commodities to be carried on the rail line.
- Projects that help maintain access across physical barriers such as a body of water (e.g. bridge repair).
Public benefit examples:
- Prevent disruption to rail and marine access due to bridge closure.
- Decrease potential for bridge closure and loss of access for rail customers.
Possible reporting measures:
- Annual bridge inspection reports and Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) incident reports that document by month the number of bridge failures for a period that begins upon award of the grant contract and extends at least one year after project completion.
- Carload reports showing the number of carloads carried over [Bridge Name/Subdivision Name] over a 12-month period before and after project completion.
Capacity
- Projects that allow for increased maximum car weights.
- Projects that allow for increased carloads and/or tonnage moved by existing customers.
- Projects that increase yard or siding capacity.
Public benefit examples:
- Increase tonnage and/or volume of railcars utilizing the [Subdivision Name/Facility Name] by X percent or by X carloads over current levels within five years.
- Increase siding capacity on [Subdivision Name].
- Increase the volume of [Commodity] transported from [Location 1] to [Location 2].
Possible reporting measures:
- Reports showing the number of railcars and overall tonnage utilizing the [Railyard/Facility Name] over a 12-month period before and after project completion.
- Reports showing the increase in siding capacity before and after project completion.
- Report showing the volume of [Commodity] transported from [Location 1] to [Location 2].
Efficiency
- Projects that result in an increased FRA track class.
- Projects that result in the removal of slow orders or otherwise make improvements that reduce trip times and/or improves utility.
- Improvements to make railyards or the loading/unloading of railcars more efficient.
Public benefit examples:
- Increase FRA track class from [FRA class] to [FRA Class].
- Increase efficiency of [Yard/Subdivision Name].
- Improve efficiency by reducing the number of slow orders on [Subdivision Name].
- Improve efficiency by reducing the frequency of crossing blockages in [City/Village/Township Name].
Possible reporting measures:
- Employee timetables that document the maximum operating speeds for this section of track before and after project completion.
- Documentation demonstrating the removal of slow orders in [Subdivision/Facility Name] after project completion.
- General Order documenting the reduction of track miles under slow orders.
- Reports showing the frequency of crossing blockages before and after project completion.
Public safety
- Crossing eliminations or other motorist risk reduction.
- Improvements to rail corridors carrying hazardous materials.
- Adding hotbox detectors or other defect detection equipment.
- Projects that address derailment sites or risks.
Public benefit examples:
- Improve local air quality by [method of calculating improvement in air quality].
- Improve public safety by replacing and/or adding defect detection equipment.
- Improve public safety through a [%] reduction in rail defects through tie, rail and ballast replacement.
Possible reporting measures:
- Report showing equipment emission calculations before and after project completion.
- Carload reports for a 12-month period before and after project completion that calculate the estimated number of heavy truck trips averted.
- Report showing locations where new equipment was installed and annual statements detailing any derailments in the project area.
- Report showing the number of defects between [MP] and [MP] identified through an inspection before and after project completion.